This theory makes sense

Baby drowns. GA does not call 911 because he knew they would do autopsy and reveal he had abused her like he did Casey. He tells Casey she is dead and he will handle it, so they don't blame her for being neglectful.. She retreats back into her fantasy world. He arranges ton hide the body until decamp happens and frames Casey. He has some tie with Thompson and kronk to hide the body. This is where his big money loss came from. He left obvious evidence to lead to Casey.

KathyO wrote:Baby drowns. GA does not call 911 because he knew they would do autopsy and reveal he had abused her like he did Casey. He tells Casey she is dead and he will handle it, so they don't blame her for being neglectful.. She retreats back into her fantasy world. He arranges ton hide the body until decamp happens and frames Casey. He has some tie with Thompson and kronk to hide the body. This is where his big money loss came from. He left obvious evidence to lead to Casey.

KathyO... Oh boy someone other than Casey is nuts or you've been drinking Bozo booze.

I've always thought that Casey had either sold Caylee for sex or that she had beat her to death in a fit of rage. I've thought this because in my mind there has to be some reason why she did not want the body found.

I hadn't thought of your scenario.

Casey does exhibit many, many symptoms of a sexually abused person. Her hatred of her mother fits in with Cindy knowing and doing nothing.

I'll need to mull this one over.

However, regardless of what happened to Casey during her childhood, nothing excused her murdering Caylee. Nothing.

If it were accidental, she should have called 911 REGARDLESS of the consequences.

OK, I've mulled this over. Casey would never have sat in a jail cell for 3 years if she could have implicated ANYONE else in Caylee's murder. She is a sociopath and that precludes your hypothesis from being a reality.

Which leads me back to Casey murdered Caylee. In a fit of rage? We will probably never know. Sociopaths have only one truth, and that is how events impact them.

In any case, Casey murdered Caylee. We just don't know the details.

I am not convinced it was murder. Too many holes in that theory. Loving bonded mom just suddenly decides to be the devil? Why kill a child her mom wanted to raise. We can't expect rational behavior from irrational people. How did she die. Who killed her. For what motive. Could someone else have done it. Too many questions without answers.

KathyO wrote:I am not convinced it was murder. Too many holes in that theory. Loving bonded mom just suddenly decides to be the devil? Why kill a child her mom wanted to raise. We can't expect rational behavior from irrational people. How did she die. Who killed her. For what motive. Could someone else have done it. Too many questions without answers.

How do you explain her month of whoring and partying? Her failure to report Caylee "missing"?

I think we have the answers to the most important questions. We just don't have the minute details.

Kathy, why are you just now posting about this horrendous crime?

I have been watching every day. Just thought I would offer an alternative theory. A lot falls into place with it. Casey may have been whoring, lying, stealing, etc but that doesn't make her a murderer. I think she is not used to showing emotion. She may grieve like so many I've seen working in hospice--cralwl into the bottle and not care anymore. I don't like her but I don't think the state proved it's case.

How about the computer searches for chloroform (84 hits) in March 2008 when no one was home but Casey?

How about the decomp and chloroform in the trunk? The hair with the death band in the trunk? Baez at Casey's bond hearing stated that Casey had been in sole possession of her car.

Why does Casey tell a friend she had taken care of the dead animal plastered to her car?

How was Caylee dressed in a shirt that Cindy (who did the family's laundry) had never seen, but was worn by Caylee in a photograph with Casey?

Why didn't Casey come clean during any one of her interviews with LE? It was the perfect opportunity to tell the truth and protect herself.

Why would Casey sit in jail for almost 3 years for an accidental death?

Why is there absolutely no other evidence of sexual abuse or molestation?

People try to cover up murders by staging accidents. Who in their right mind covers up an accident by staging a murder?

Why would George want to frame Casey for murder?

KathyO wrote:Baby drowns. GA does not call 911 because he knew they would do autopsy and reveal he had abused her like he did Casey. He tells Casey she is dead and he will handle it, so they don't blame her for being neglectful.. She retreats back into her fantasy world. He arranges ton hide the body until decamp happens and frames Casey. He has some tie with Thompson and kronk to hide the body. This is where his big money loss came from. He left obvious evidence to lead to Casey.

KathyO...I have thought the same thing as you.

Call me crazy but it just makes sense. From the beginning I had a weird feeling about George. He is an x cop, he knows the law. He felt he was above the law. He molested Casey for years. She learned how to lie. Her whole life was a lie. I suspect at one point Casey might have tried to tell her mom about the abuse. Her mom could not let herself believe such a horrible thing about the man she was married to. Afterall he was a cop, his job was to serve and protect. Casey felt betrayed by her mother. George killed one of their pets and made sure Casey knew he did it because she had told her mother of the sexual abuse. In fact, anytime George felt threatened that Casey might tell one of the family pets would turn up dead. Didn't anyone notice all the time her Attorney spent on discussing the family pets. I believe her Attorney knows the truth along with Casey and her dad.

Somewhere in her childhood, George involved his son in the sexual abuse. I watched Casey and Lee cry in court, as if they shared a big family secret. A secret to painful for either of them to disclose. When Casey found out she was pregnant Lee became the outcast in the family, totally cut off...somewhere I heard he was told to "leave it alone". I believe this was out of fear he might spill the beans about his dad. Lee might have even thought his dad was the father of caseys unborn child. Didn't anyone notice how Lee avoid both his parents through it all.

And Cindy strikes me as a woman who does not live in reality. She lied about making the internet searches out of guilt. Cause somewhere in the back of her mind she wonders if Casey was telling the truth about her husband. His affair had to put some doubt in her mind. I believe Casey might have made the internet searches for ways to get rid of her dad. Didn't someone also search "how to break a neck?" She knew her own daughter was getting to the age where she was molested, so to protect her own daughter she wanted to take her dad out, to protect Caylee. Maybe she was already to late.

We all know George lies as well, he denies having his affair. I don't believe Georges suicide attempt was real, he wrote that letter in case he had to cover his own ass of having any knowledge of what really happened.

George knows what happened. Casey knows what happened. George said himself it was an accident that snowballed.

Thats why Casey left the house never to return. As far as her partying, she did what she could to numb her pain. A lifetime of pain. Always pretending everything was wonderful and good when it really wasn't. George told her as he had always told her...act as if nothing was wrong. He would take care of it all. George then began his task of covering his own ass and setting up Casey. And why would he feel the need to cover his own ass? Exactly as KathyO posted...an autopsy would prove someone had been molesting her, and we all know who Casey would be pointing the finger at...her dad. Only with that kind of evidence would anyone listen to Caseys allegations. So he got rid of his granddaughters body. And framed his daughter. Cold and heartless George.

And now justice will never be done. If there is a god, justice will be done someday. Most likely to George.

Wow some people are so completely nuts its scary. George hadn't been a cop for about 20yrs, he was the only one in that family that had tried to cooperate with the police at the beginning hoping that his granddaughter would be found. Yes he knew by the smell in that car that Casey had done something to Caylee. The only thing going on in that family IMO is that Cindy never wanted to upset "sweetheart" so she pretended she wasn't pregnant, etc etc etc, and because Cindy is very much like Casey, Lee and George don't want to upset Cindy either. Just ignore and hope for the best was the way in that home. Of course JMO, anything is possible I suppose.

MichiganPam wrote:Wow some people are so completely nuts its scary. George hadn't been a cop for about 20yrs, he was the only one in that family that had tried to cooperate with the police at the beginning hoping that his granddaughter would be found. Yes he knew by the smell in that car that Casey had done something to Caylee. The only thing going on in that family IMO is that Cindy never wanted to upset "sweetheart" so she pretended she wasn't pregnant, etc etc etc, and because Cindy is very much like Casey, Lee and George don't want to upset Cindy either. Just ignore and hope for the best was the way in that home. Of course JMO, anything is possible I suppose.

Holy Cow Pam some people are totally nuts.....I so agree with all you said, Casey murdered her little girl and that is the end of the story.....the whole Anthony family is dysfunctional, but they did not murder this child, their guilt is in the cover up and the pretense Caylee was missing....they new from DAY 1 with the smell of that car that Caylee was gone

MichiganPam wrote:Wow some people are so completely nuts its scary. George hadn't been a cop for about 20yrs, he was the only one in that family that had tried to cooperate with the police at the beginning hoping that his granddaughter would be found. Yes he knew by the smell in that car that Casey had done something to Caylee. The only thing going on in that family IMO is that Cindy never wanted to upset "sweetheart" so she pretended she wasn't pregnant, etc etc etc, and because Cindy is very much like Casey, Lee and George don't want to upset Cindy either. Just ignore and hope for the best was the way in that home. Of course JMO, anything is possible I suppose.

"Once a cop, always a cop" I doubt he forgot his training, even after 20 years.

And why wouldn't George cooperate, he is the most guilty, so he knew he had to cover his ass by not causing any suspicion on himself.

lovinourgrandkids wrote:

MichiganPam wrote:Wow some people are so completely nuts its scary. George hadn't been a cop for about 20yrs, he was the only one in that family that had tried to cooperate with the police at the beginning hoping that his granddaughter would be found. Yes he knew by the smell in that car that Casey had done something to Caylee. The only thing going on in that family IMO is that Cindy never wanted to upset "sweetheart" so she pretended she wasn't pregnant, etc etc etc, and because Cindy is very much like Casey, Lee and George don't want to upset Cindy either. Just ignore and hope for the best was the way in that home. Of course JMO, anything is possible I suppose.

"Once a cop, always a cop" I doubt he forgot his training, even after 20 years.

And why wouldn't George cooperate, he is the most guilty, so he knew he had to cover his ass by not causing any suspicion on himself.

Lovinourgrandkids, I really don't mean to be rude but there is nothing you've said that I could remotely agree with. Please read this article, perhaps it will help you to think more clearly.More: http://www.law.com/jsp/nlj/PubArticleNLJ.jsp?id=1202508318214&Reasonable_doubts_in_the_Casey_Anthony_trial&slreturn=1&hbxlogin

MichiganPam wrote:

lovinourgrandkids wrote:

MichiganPam wrote:Wow some people are so completely nuts its scary. George hadn't been a cop for about 20yrs, he was the only one in that family that had tried to cooperate with the police at the beginning hoping that his granddaughter would be found. Yes he knew by the smell in that car that Casey had done something to Caylee. The only thing going on in that family IMO is that Cindy never wanted to upset "sweetheart" so she pretended she wasn't pregnant, etc etc etc, and because Cindy is very much like Casey, Lee and George don't want to upset Cindy either. Just ignore and hope for the best was the way in that home. Of course JMO, anything is possible I suppose.

"Once a cop, always a cop" I doubt he forgot his training, even after 20 years.

And why wouldn't George cooperate, he is the most guilty, so he knew he had to cover his ass by not causing any suspicion on himself.

Lovinourgrandkids, I really don't mean to be rude but there is nothing you've said that I could remotely agree with. Please read this article, perhaps it will help you to think more clearly.More: http://www.law.com/jsp/nlj/PubArticleNLJ.jsp?id=1202508318214&Reasonable_doubts_in_the_Casey_Anthony_trial&slreturn=1&hbxlogin

MichiganPam thanks for the link, I think if the jury would have taken more time going over the evidence, they would have at least found her guilty of something. She is the childs mother and it was her responsibility to keep Caylee safe. There is no excuse in the world for reporting her child missing when she knew all along she was dead, whether by accident or something worse, I just don't see how she could have kept quiet during all the many searches that were going on. She knew her child was laying out there somewhere in the woods, exposed to the elements and wild animals, for that alone she should have got prison time. The jurors should have been able to agree that punishment was warranted for that, at the very least. She should have never walked. Sad case.